Should Customer Loyalty Cards Have a “Use Tax”?
Monday, April 28th, 2008There’s a very interesting sales tax issue brewing here in Boulder, as reported in the local paper. Seems that someone in city hall has gotten the inspiration to tax a local coffee house, Vics, for the hundreds of free cups of coffee they hand out to frequent customers.
Lots of companies in Boulder have the customer loyalty device in question: a frequent buyer punch card or similar. I have about a dozen of them in my wallet or car glove compartment and they’re all generally the same: get ten punches and the eleventh is on the house. Whether it’s an expensive coffee drink, a burrito, a smoothie or even a sandwich, companies from Safeway to Wahoo’s Fish Tacos have these ubiquitous cards.
According to the paper, Vic’s owes the city approximately $3,000 in unpaid sales tax, which is being labeled “use tax”. Rather than just pay it or register a complaint through the chamber of commerce, Vic’s has brought its fight public by putting up a Web site and hosting a fund raiser for its legal fund. You can check out the site at Vic’s Espresso.com.
I’m torn on this issue because on the one hand, I really like the loyalty card idea and it does help me decide to return to my favorite haunts on a regular basis, but tax revenue from commercial transactions are also an important source of funds for the city and the myriad of services I enjoy as a resident too.



